Climbing Parnassus has ratings and 62 reviews. TheRose said: This is a paradigm-shifting book. I was flabbergasted by how much I really didn’t unders. “Discussions of educational reform often involve windy talk of a “return to the classics,” yet rarely do would-be reformers go so far as to advocate a return to. Tracy Lee Simmons’s book, Climbing Parnassus, is a tour-de-force. Simmons addresses the current state of education, which is dismal, to a.
|Published (Last):||28 January 2010|
|PDF File Size:||18.88 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||19.47 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
To be fair, while I prefer the classical languages, you could learn any mother language, and that would be just as good in developing your memory. Theirs were not child-centered societies. P21 And education he said it’s not the mayor possession of knowledge, but the ability to reflect upon it and grow in wisdom. To answer these questions, Simmons turns to history to explore how thinkers since antiquity have thought about education, and in doing so one is made to see just how far our modern conception of it has strayed in both form and fun This is a fantastic book which challenges present day dogma regarding the role apo,ogia schools and what their goals should be.
From a historical perspective, I think the book can be given a fair reading; especially in the second part.
Something for me still to ponder. The tor is exalted above the rose. Disclosure of Material Connection: Parnassus truly is an exercise that expands our minds such that we can learn to perceive both greatness and goodness.
They have great value, both intellectual and cultural’but he proceeds to make a case for reading poetry only in the original Simmons addresses the current state of education, climbnig is dismal, to a classical education. Amazon Renewed Refurbished products with a warranty. However, the complicated, repetitive and self-contradictory flow of ideas does not assist: P31 Liberty have a double edge, fit only to be handled by Justin virtuous man; too bad and dissolute, it becomes a mischief unwieldy in their own hands.
I can build rockets to Mars and beyond, but it cannot tell us whether it’s wise to go there. I appreciate the perspective and motivation it gave me. Yet never have so many thought they know so much.
English Choose a language for shopping.
Climbing Parnassus: A New Apologia for Greek and Latin | Circe Institute
If anyone has a different understanding regarding this, please let me know. Similarly, classics may well provide mental and moral attainments, and its languages do exercise our minds in more ways than one, but it is important to be discriminatory about ‘the greatest thoughts’ that emanated from this ancient world.
What career-minded politician would dare to push such an unrewarding barrow? Though I will continue to wrestle with some of his points in relation to my own worldview, I will certainly re-read “Climbin As someone not in the habit of reading higher level writing, I initially found this to be a difficult read. It can drive us to build new roads and bridges, but I cannot explain where we want to go.
For the inner is eternal. His persuasive witness to the unique, now all-but-forgotten advantages of study in, and of, the classical languages constitutes a bracing reminder of the genuine aims of a truly liberal education.
No results are guaranteed. Return to Book Page.
Climbing Parnassus: A New Apologia for Greek and Latin
As someone not in the habit of reading higher level writing, I initially found this to be a difficult read. P The true aim of education is to develop the man and woman who are something bigger and finer than a mere piece of mechanism designed to fit into place in a practical world which is devoid of aspiration and idealism, breath division in imagination, and forever denied the privilege of tasting the things of the spirit which alone is life. Today, news media, books and new technology bombard us with new information constantly.
A classical education was to enhance the soul.
Moreover, their minds and hearts were shaped by both the classical education and the pulpit. Buy the selected items together This item: Jun 10, Julie rated it it was amazing Shelves: This sentiment provides more ammunition as if they need it! Would you like to tell us about a lower price? applogia
Climbing Parnassus: A New Apologia for Greek and Latin – Tracy Lee Simmons – Google Books
No one should disagree that, ‘such an education is eminently practical’ The Humanities were once an area of discipline and rigor. To ask other readers questions about Climbing Parnassusplease sign up. Today, we’ve had to make room in our universities for remedial English.
There is a bibliography, but it contains no editions of classical authors, to whom S. We have not indeed jettisoned the hope and drive that keep us working for a better world that’s the good newsbut we have forgotten to cultivate ourselves as individuals. Content was everything, form nothing His technical distinction is discomforting: That is how inspiring this book is. ,atin and Greek prose and verse composition represent the true path — we’ll be ‘sweatier It makes him think he is enjoying poems he can’t construe.
How did liberal education go so wrong? Simmons argues that we need an elite to guide and shape culture.